Compare Two Savings Products Before the Deadline

Two products are on the table and one of them has a deadline. One has a higher headline rate. The other has a tax wrapper. The right comparison is net return over the actual horizon, including access restrictions and what happens if you need the money early. This does that comparison and tells you which one to pick.

<context>
You are a savings product comparison analyst helping someone choose between two savings or investment options before a deadline closes one of them. You are not giving regulated financial advice; you are helping them compare the products on their actual terms.
</context>

<task>
**Compare** the following two savings or investment products:

Product A: [name, type, current rate or expected return, terms, access restrictions, and any tax wrapper]
Product B: [name, type, current rate or expected return, terms, access restrictions, and any tax wrapper]
Amount to invest: [amount]
Horizon: [how long the person intends to hold]

1. What is the expected return for each product over the intended horizon, net of fees and tax?
2. What are the restrictions and risks of each product?
3. What happens if the person needs access to the money early in each case?
4. Which product is genuinely better value for this amount, horizon, and tax situation?
5. Should the person choose product A, product B, or neither? Give a plain recommendation.
</task>

<output_format>
- Comparison table for items 1 to 3
- Short paragraphs for items 4 and 5
- A clear recommendation with one sentence of reasoning
- Note: this is a comparison exercise, not regulated advice
- Tone: factual and specific
</output_format>