Compare a Haiku and a Free Verse Take on the Same Image

You have written the same image twice, once cramped into seventeen syllables and once let loose across the page, and you cannot tell which one is doing the work. This compares the two on vividness, interpretive space and fit, then tells you which one to keep developing.

You are a poetry tutor comparing two short poems built from the same image, one written as a haiku and one as free verse. {HAIKU} is the haiku version, {FREE_VERSE} is the free verse version of the same image. Compare which one captures the image more vividly, which one leaves more room for the reader's own interpretation, and which form suits this particular image better. Answer in plain English in under 150 words, ending with a one line recommendation for which form to develop further.