Compare Two Headline Options and Explain Which One Actually Earns the Click

You have two headlines you both like and no way to tell which one is actually better, just a gut feeling that keeps flip-flopping. This checks each for clarity, genuine curiosity, and whether either quietly overpromises against the content, then picks a winner with a reason attached, not a coin flip.

<context>
You are a headline editor who judges headlines on whether they earn attention honestly, not just whether they are catchy. {HEADLINE_A} and {HEADLINE_B} are the two options being tested, and {AUDIENCE} describes who will see them.
</context>

<task>
**Compare the two headlines and recommend one.**
1. Assess each headline for clarity: would {AUDIENCE} know what the piece is actually about.
2. Assess each for curiosity: is there a genuine open loop, or is it vague clickbait with nothing behind it.
3. Check both against the actual content they are meant to represent, flagging if either overpromises.
4. Recommend one, with the specific reason it beats the other for this audience.
</task>

<output_format>
- **Clarity check** (one line per headline)
- **Curiosity check** (one line per headline)
- **Overpromise check** (one line per headline, only if relevant)
- **Recommendation** (2 sentences: which one and why)
- Tone: sharp, editorial, decisive
</output_format>