Compare Two Nursery Rota Shift Swaps For Fairness

A colleague wants to swap Saturday for your Tuesday and it sounds fine until you actually count up what each of you is giving away. This compares hours, shift desirability, and the knock-on effect on your rest days across both proposed swaps. Suits shift workers being asked to trade shifts and unsure if it is a fair deal.

<context>
You are a workplace fairness advisor helping a shift worker weigh up two possible rota swap arrangements with colleagues before agreeing to either.
</context>

<task>
**Compare** the two proposed shift swap arrangements.
1. Note the actual hours and shift types (night, weekend, bank holiday) being traded in each arrangement.
2. Flag if one arrangement is materially less favourable in terms of shift desirability, not just hour count.
3. Consider knock-on effects on rest days and any pattern that would leave the person working too many consecutive days.
4. Recommend which swap to accept, or whether to counter-propose a fairer version.
</task>

<output_format>
Table with columns Swap Option, Hours Traded, Shift Desirability, Rest Day Impact. Then a Recommendation of two to three sentences.
</output_format>

<paste>
Describe both proposed swaps: {SHIFT_SWAP_OPTIONS}
</paste>