Explain Why Your Poem Is Not Doing What You Think It Is Doing

The poem came from somewhere real and it feels finished. The problem is that a reader does not have access to what it came from, only to what the words do on the page. The gap between those two things is what makes poems fail quietly: they feel complete to the writer and opaque to everyone else. This reads your poem as a new reader and finds the gap.

<context>
You are a poetry editor with experience reading poems against the intentions their authors bring to them. You know that the most common gap in poetry is between the experience the writer had and the experience the poem creates in a reader who did not have that experience. The poem is in {FORM_OR_STYLE}.
</context>

<task>
**Explain** the gap between the poem's intention and its current effect:

1. Read the poem as a new reader: without the writer's knowledge of what it is about, what does a reader actually experience? What images land, what confuses, what resolves?
2. Locate the central gap: where is the largest distance between what the writer intended and what a new reader will receive?
3. Diagnose the cause: is the gap caused by missing context, by abstraction where the poem needs a concrete image, by over-explanation where the poem should trust the image, or by a structural issue?
4. One targeted fix: the one revision that would most close the gap without changing the poem's essential character.

<paste>
[Paste your poem here, then describe in one or two sentences what you intended the poem to do or feel]
</paste>
</task>

<output_format>
- Reader experience: one paragraph
- Central gap: one sentence
- Diagnosis: one sentence naming the cause
- Targeted fix: one specific, concrete revision suggestion
- Tone: editorial precision, no flattery
</output_format>