Critique a Game You Love So You Can Recommend It More Honestly

You love it and you want someone else to love it and so you sell it and they play it and they do not love it and you feel like they played it wrong. The problem with recommending games you love is that your enthusiasm obscures the things that would tell someone it is not for them. This gives you an honest critique that includes the real weaknesses, who it is not for, and the thing you are probably too close to it to see, so you can give a recommendation worth trusting.

I want to recommend a game I love to someone but I want to give them an honest picture rather than just enthusiasm. The game is {GAME_NAME}. Help me critique it fairly by covering: what it does genuinely well and why that matters, what its real weaknesses are (not the things fans dismiss but the things that have actually put people off), who specifically this game is and is not for, and what to tell someone so they can make an informed decision about whether to try it. Include one thing I might be too close to the game to see clearly. Format this as something I could actually say to someone considering playing it.